Ravichandran Ashwin, a prominent Indian cricketer, has publicly defended young pacer Harshit Rana, despite having previously questioned his selection for the ODI series against Australia. This defense comes after India`s head coach, Gautam Gambhir, vehemently criticized Krishnamachari Srikkanth for alleging that Rana was chosen merely for being a `constant yes man`. Aligning with Gambhir`s viewpoint, Ashwin stressed the crucial need to avoid `below the belt` or `personal` attacks in any form of criticism, asserting that such negativity has no place in discourse.
The Essence of Fair Critique
Speaking on his YouTube channel, Ashwin reiterated his long-standing belief that no player should ever be subjected to personal attacks. He elaborated that while professional critique is acceptable, its nature fundamentally changes when it crosses into personal territory. Citing his own experiences, Ashwin mentioned Sanjay Manjrekar, who has frequently criticized him throughout his career. Yet, Ashwin maintains no grudge, clearly distinguishing between constructive criticism and personal slander. He articulated, “What they say might be right or wrong; as long as the criticism doesn`t get personal, I am fine with it.”
Impact of Negativity and Social Media Trolling
Ashwin expressed profound empathy for Rana, particularly concerning the prevalence of social media trolling and negative content. He warned that such harsh and public attacks could be mentally devastating for a player on the verge of representing their country, and equally distressing for their families and friends. He emphasized that while it is entirely appropriate to critique a player`s skill, their style of play, or their overall performance, criticism “shouldn`t get personal.”
Recognizing the widespread nature of such content, Ashwin commented, “It may be funny once or twice, but it shouldn`t be a running theme.” He attributed the proliferation of negativity to audience demand, stating, “Negativity sells these days. They sell whatever is in demand. We should avoid consuming such content.”
Addressing Hypocrisy in Public Opinion
The veteran all-rounder further highlighted a perceived hypocrisy in public discourse. He questioned whether those currently targeting Harshit Rana would be the same individuals celebrating him if he were to perform exceptionally well in future matches. Ashwin observed, “Everyone`s targeting Harshit Rana left, right and centre. Let me ask you one thing: if the same Harshit performs well next year, will the same people put him on the same pedestal and celebrate him?”
Ashwin concluded his message by expressing significant disappointment with the prevailing culture of `trash talk`. He passionately urged his audience to view cricket purely as a sport and to refrain from consuming or propagating negative content, offering a poignant reminder that the subject of such criticism could easily be a friend, family member, or loved one.
